Rogue refunds of Class 2 NI due to HMRC failure
HMRC has incorrectly refunded Class 2 NI to some self-employed taxpayers. What should you do if you get an unexpected payment?

Self-employed taxpayers with profits below £6,725 can voluntarily pay Class 2 NI to maintain their entitlement to certain benefits, most importantly, it adds a year to their state pension entitlement record. HMRC appears to have failed to meet the payment deadline for voluntary Class 2 NI for the 2022/23 tax year. As a result, in some cases, its systems have automatically rejected the payment and returned up to £163.80 to the taxpayer. Unfortunately, HMRC is not yet proactively contacting taxpayers to resolve the issue, which means unless affected taxpayers take corrective action, they may lose their entitlement to NI-related benefits for 2022/23.
The Low Incomes Tax Reform Group is recommending that those who have received a refund to call HMRC’s National Insurance helpline on 0300 200 3500 to repay the NI. It's not possible to simply pay the amount to the self-assessment account.
Related Topics
-
What’s a trivial benefit worth to employers?
The tax and NI exemption for trivial benefits is much misunderstood, but nonetheless very useful to employers. When can you use it, what are its advantages and are there any pitfalls to watch out for?
-
Should you agree to your customer’s self-billing request?
A customer wants to adopt a self-billing system, meaning they will issue invoices on your behalf and charge VAT or otherwise. Can you refuse their request and what are the risks of accepting?
-
Travel expenses - exempt or not?
You have several employees who travel from home or their workplace in the course of doing their job. Naturally, you meet the cost of their travel but should you be deducting tax and NI from the payments, or are they exempt?